So, somehow, I missed what was probably the biggest box office surprise of 2026 in theaters. To be fair, I tend to skip horror movies. The one genre I might have less interest in are rom-coms. I’ve even gotten more into musicals in the last few years. Sure, I do see horror movies. I even genuinely love many of them. But somehow, I skipped Obsession, a movie that sold a whole lot of tickets, particularly in relation to how much it cost to make it. It’s been out long enough, and been so big in pop culture, that I basically knew the plot without seeing it, a movie that retold the old story about the Monkey’s Paw, except writer/director Curry Barker may have been inspired by a “Treehouse of Horror” segment from The Simpsons as opposed to the W.W. Jacobs short story.
OK, I had to look Jacobs up as the original author, but the point stands. Also, Obsession just dropped on Netflix, giving me a chance to see it. I mean, I wasn’t going to start a Peacock account just to see one horror movie, no matter how much people were raving about it…except for my pal Watson. He didn’t like this one. And I may be giving out more spoilers than usual for this review since the movie does seem to have seeped into the ether all on its own, so you’ve been warned.

Bear (Michael Johnston) has a problem: a crush on his longtime friend Nikki (Inde Navarrette). However, he takes some advice from his friend Ian (frequent Barker collaborator Cooper Tomlinson) and doesn’t do anything like, you know, tell Nikki, preferring to stew in silence even as another friend Sarah (Megan Lawless) clearly has a thing for Bear herself. On a whim, Bear goes to get Nikki a gift and buys a “One Wish Willow,” a novelty item that promises the user a single wish. Bear decides the way to get what he wants is to wish for it. True, he doesn’t think this will work, but then, well, Nikki suddenly really likes him.
Or does she? Nikki is acting a little weird. She tells some lies, and when she is caught, she makes odd faces and screeches “no” a whole bunch of times, Her behavior is clearly different now. She is clingy, doesn’t seem to sleep much, and just appears in places with extreme bouts of jealousy. If this is love, it’s just disturbing…at best. Can Bear do the right thing?
Normally, I am largely in agreement with Watson on the subject of movies, but not this time. Then again, horror movies is usually where we differ. I rather liked how Obsession turned out. A lot of that is thanks to Navarrette’s performance as Nikki. The pre-wish Nikki that we barely get to see comes across as a sweet, charming young woman, and Barker’s script makes it clear this is someone with her own hopes and dreams, all of which seems to vanish the second Bear makes his wish. Johnston is also pretty good in his role as the “nice guy” (who isn’t really that nice in the grand scheme of things), but Navarrette is the one doing the heavy lifting here, going from friendly girl-next-door to this excessively weird and off-putting creature that cries at the drop of a hat and can’t act like a normal human being for more than five minutes.
Barker’s script and capable direction is the other thing going right here. Bear makes his wish and gets what he wants, or so he thinks. The longer things go on, the more the movie makes it obvious that Bear is an emotionally-stunted man who made a childish decision and got exactly what he wanted, only to realize he doesn’t actually want it, or at least not the way he got it. Discordant music in the soundtrack, flashes of the real Nikki, even making it clear Bear could have been very happy with Sarah instead all make for a movie where a young woman had her whole life ripped apart by one guy who couldn’t handle an emotional attraction like an adult.
Grade: A-
0 Comments