I had what I thought was an interesting introduction to this review where I talk about watching where Oscar-winning actors go after they win the big prize. I thought the new Victorian Psycho starred Anora actress Mikey Madison, but it was actually Longlegs actress Maika Monroe. Those are, you know, two different actresses. Granted, both are American actresses, and either would have been the lone Americans in Victorian Psycho‘s main cast.
Anyway, it’s Monroe’s movie. How did it turn out?

The movie opens with Winifred Notty (Monroe) looking directly into the camera. Her head is level with the frame, but she is holding her head at an angle, so her head is level within the frame. but her body and the background are not. Her narration says she is the only sane person she knows. As it is, she may not be very sane, but she may not be wrong about being the sanest person she knows. Winifred has just gotten a new position as governess for the wealthy Pounds family. Mr. Pounds (Jason Isaacs)went wropgm believes in phrenology. Mrs. Pounds (Ruth Wilson) expects everything to be held to a high standard and that Winifred will make sure their son Andrew (Jacobi Jupe) is smart but not too smart while his older sister Drusilla (Evie Templeton), well, she needs less of that sort of thing. Sure, Winifred says she is going to be good, but then a severed human ear falls out of her luggage.
So, Winifred is a killer? Rumors followed her last appointment where something always went wrong. She also has some odd ideas about how to handle suffering. But this is a strange world she’s in, where owning a pineapple is a status symbol and the people Winifred works for are also fairly awful in their own ways. The one seemingly innocent person is Ms. Lamb the nurse (Thomasin McKenzie), but she’s rather naive even as she becomes what may be Winifred’s first actual friend. Winifred wants something about the Pound family. Will anyone survive if she doesn’t get it? Or even if she does?
Honestly, I wasn’t sure what to make of this one. Monroe makes these odd faces to suggest she is unwell, but the other characters also tend to be these exaggerated things that seem to think nothing of the sort of behavior that doesn’t justify any of the violence that may be coming their way, but it does go a long way to explaining why Winifred should think of herself as the sanest person she knows. She’s not sane, but she lives in an insane world.
That said, the final act didn’t sit well with me, and that was more due to execution than anything else. The movie has some interesting shots, such as point-of-view shots of things sitting in Winifred’s handful or various moments where her head stayed level on-screen no matter what else was happening. The movie may have been aiming for satirical, but it isn’t terribly funny. It aimed for disturbing and didn’t quite make it there either. Then again, nothing against Ms. Monroe, but maybe it would have worked out better with Mikey Madison. Or not. I don’t think either Mikey or Maika could have quite made this one work.
Grade: C
0 Comments